In the final minutes of play, New York Athletic Club is awarded a penalty kick, with the score 2-1, NYAC can bring the game equal, but Brooklyn Italians goalkeeper Pasquale Tolomeo makes the big save to secure the championship for his team. This was the third meeting as Brooklyn lost to NYAC in league play on April 05 of this year. Brooklyn Italians who had played NYAC last week and had lost 2-1 in the D'Arpinio Cup State Finals came to Randalls Island determined and very focused on winning the Cosmopolitan Soccer League Reserve League Championship.